Would depend on age and goals. If your goals are more financial and there is a short amount of time to reach them, you may need to. If you goal is to be fulfilled and you have some level of comfort then you may get to choose the lower paying one. Having a fulfilled life outside of work, with hobbies where you can be fulfilled will also go a long way.
At this age and level of my life I would prefer a high paying job. I can seek for fulfillment of what I love when I grow older... the bills don't consider if you love what u are doing or not they just keep piling up..