Will the teaching position disappear because of AI?
A few days ago, I listened to a Czech video cast where the idea was that in a few years, the teaching position will lose its relevance.
This seems like a quite realistic prognosis to me, because:
The teaching position is not particularly valued,
AI knows more information than a teacher,
AI does not sharply confront the user, which encourages people to ask questions and think critically (this can sometimes not be said about the school system)
More and more young people prefer to communicate with Chatgpt than with an "educational authority"
I'd like to know how you see this statement, and maybe the Question for parents out there:
How do you raise children when it comes to studying and working with artificial intelligence? 🤓
Replies
Hey Nika! I always enjoy your discussions—they’re so thought-provoking. Even when I don’t write something, I find myself coming back to read the conversations you start.
On this topic, I think there’s a very high probability that AI will replace teaching jobs, at least in part. The difference in brain capacity and efficiency between humans and AI is clear as day, especially with how human-like AI sounds nowadays. That said, I do believe human teachers have unique teaching styles that AI can’t fully replicate. From my own little experience as a teacher, I’ve noticed that some students need very specific approaches to learn effectively. For example, the "educational authority" style—some kids actually thrive under stricter guidance, while others don’t. But then again, with how fast tech is advancing, who’s to say AI won’t eventually adapt to those nuances too?
To answer your question for parents, I’m not one yet, but if I were, I wouldn’t mind AI educating my children—especially considering my own knowledge limitations. However, I wouldn’t let AI take over everything. I’d want my kids to grow into humans who can work with AI, not depend on it entirely. They shouldn’t need AI to validate or dictate their lives, but rather use it as a tool while staying in control of their own choices, emotions, and humanity. After all, critical thinking, creativity, and emotional expression are things no algorithm can truly replace.
What do you think—could AI ever fully mimic the human touch in teaching? Or will there always be something irreplaceable about a real teacher?
minimalist phone: creating folders
@rani_zagita Thank you, Zagita, pleased to read that you like my random writings! :D :)
As for teachers, I have to say that some were strict elements in my life, and now I wonder if that's a good thing, because an overly authoritative approach can oppress some people. 😂
I would probably opt for predominantly AI teaching, but a few hours per week to attend some classes for human interaction and peers.
But my opinion is still forming...
Nothing will disappear, but everything will evolve. The rise of AI will reshape every profession, and adapting to it will be essential. Teaching must move beyond simply delivering information; it must focus on shaping character and values. Educators have a responsibility to raise a generation rooted in ethics and morals, capable of using technology wisely and responsibly.
@soufyanelf I share the same view. Well put.
minimalist phone: creating folders
@soufyanelf This could be an ideal scenario. I am just curious how things are gonna play out.
App Finder
For some subjects, I think human teachers can and should be replaced by AI to a large part.
But there are of course many things where a human teacher could be replaced only by a very advanced humanoid robot, like doing experiments in physics, chemistry, biology, learning to write by hand, and physical education of course. Also to prevent cheating in exams.
minimalist phone: creating folders
@konrad_sx Well, my take is that 80% of teachers will be replaced, 20% remaining will be in the sector of medicine, studies related to PE (if Competitions will not be replaced by physical robots) etc.
Based on my experience of being a student for over 10 years😂, I believe that learning isn't just some kind of transaction. Teachers aren't just there to teach, they're also there to manage, guide, and help students grow in character, responsibility, and self-awareness. They help us build the skills we need to handle real life, not just academic learning. And honestly, I think that's something AI would have a really hard time doing.
minimalist phone: creating folders
@feliciana_liu It has a raising aspect, no wonder, but considering how poorly it is paid compared to what is required, they will be less motivated and even less able to offer something, while AI can know more. The only benefit will be soon just socialising – to be with a human being. For some students will be a win because there could possibly be less physical bullying. On the other hand, more cyberbullying.
Hey! Very interesting question, I think this is a fascinating question about the future of education. While AI will certainly transform teaching, I believe humans will remain essential — although role of teacher will be more like a mentor, or emotional support (why not?). As you ay know, you can have all the answers, but it matters only if you can spark interest in student
minimalist phone: creating folders
@davit_mkrtchyan Do you think it will be an optional role? That only very rich families will afford "companions" for their kids?
@busmark_w_nika such a controversial question, I don't think that would be optional. Let's not forget that we have educational systems, and even if teaching position will transform, that doesn't mean it will be eliminated, or be accessible only to the rich people. Teachers existed from day 1 of human history. Worst case scenario, at least someone should teach kids how to use AI, and how not to use it. Similar issue raised, when internet become a thing. Lot's of people worried that now all knowledge is accessible with couple clicks, so education system is doomed. But as we saw, it was not the case.
I am not saying we should wait and do nothing, definitely, we need to get ready, at least we should learn how it works, and why it works, so later we can teach that to our kids :D
Maybe replaced with debates + pre-recorded lectures. No point giving same lecture every semester, it's boring for the teachers too.
minimalist phone: creating folders
@admiralrohan I think that AI will also cover this. E.g. AI will be able to correct your pronunciation. I am pretty sure that it already exists.
I don't think that the teaching position will disappear.
An example:
I used AI chat to help me with the growth of the company. The answers were still somehow generic.
I had to subscribe to Growth Mentor for more HUMAN conversations with the startup growth mentors. It was really personalized and they often approached first instead of waiting for a question like AI does. They even follow up which AI doesn't do.
Lancepilot
I think AI will definitely reshape the teaching role but great teachers do more than deliver information they inspire, mentor, and create spaces for human connection, creativity, and emotional growth, which AI can’t fully replicate.