Subscribe
Sign in
Start new thread
All
General
p/general
Share and discuss tech, products, business, startups, or product recommendations
Sean P.

Do you consider AI art legitimate art?

13
•
AI Spirals is trending now, you can create these truly one-of-a-kind art in seconds, however is it legitimate art? https://www.producthunt.com/prod...

Add a comment

Replies
Best
Artvizual
Art is perspective, and it's all about emotion. What is art to somebody else doesn't have to feel like art for you.
Sean P.
@artvizual totally agree, even the debates are ongoing, there are already portions of the population accepting this new medium
Elena Tsemirava
Maybe it depends on quality. Sometimes it is impossible to call art what recognized living “masters” do.
Sean P.
@elenat yeah mimicking is the fundamental problem as those AI was trained on the sample from the “master” , and if we look at this from the angle of junior artist mimicking the master to learn then this process is pretty much same
Salar Davari
Why not. Who said only us humans have the right to perform art? I believe there is nothing wrong with the ideal of AI art. Consider it another favor that it does for us for free.
Sean P.
@salar__davari totally agree, AI considered as tool just like Cameras+Photo and the debates still on going
Zeng
This is beautiful to look at. I love it!
Antoni Kozelski
The question of whether art created by artificial intelligence is considered legitimate art is an ongoing debate in the art world. Some argue that art created by artificial intelligence is a form of artistic expression, while others argue that art is human expression and AI is not. Ultimately, the question of whether AI art is legitimate depends on legislation and, of course, the majority opinion and their criteria in assessing the impact of AI
Sean P.
@antonikozelski yeah, when AI is used as tool and the amount of human work significantly involved then it’s consider as art. However how much is “significant” enough?
Artyom Sviridov
Well, the definition of "art" is so broad it's practically impossible to give a reasonable answer. Could I call it "art" if I really enjoyed it? Guess so. On a side note, some people, for example, don't consider video games to be art. So yeah, there's a field for discussion here.
Tedel
As an artist, definitely no. Computers just follow (its programmer's) instructions. AI art may imitate human purpose, but I doubt it will ever be able to create with purpose.