Product Hunt logo dark
  • Launches
    Coming soon
    Upcoming launches to watch
    Launch archive
    Most-loved launches by the community
    Launch Guide
    Checklists and pro tips for launching
  • Products
  • News
    Newsletter
    The best of Product Hunt, every day
    Stories
    Tech news, interviews, and tips from makers
    Changelog
    New Product Hunt features and releases
  • Forums
    Forums
    Ask questions, find support, and connect
    Streaks
    The most active community members
    Events
    Meet others online and in-person
  • Advertise
Subscribe
Sign in
bookclub

bookclub reviews

build your digital bookshelf

•16 reviews•

11 followers

  • Overview
  • Launches
  • Forums
  • Reviews
  • Team
  • Awards
  • Alternatives
  • More
  • Blog
  • •
  • Newsletter
  • •
  • Questions
  • •
  • Forums
  • •
  • Product Categories
  • •
  • Apps
  • •
  • About
  • •
  • FAQ
  • •
  • Terms
  • •
  • Privacy and Cookies
  • •
  • X.com
  • •
  • Facebook
  • •
  • Instagram
  • •
  • LinkedIn
  • •
  • YouTube
  • •
  • Advertise
© 2025 Product Hunt
Product status
Unclaimed
Awards
bookclub was ranked #2 of the day for May 17th, 2018
All Awards
Forum Threads
bookclub
p/bookclub
Jordan Gonen
Jordan Gonen
bookclub - A beautiful, simple alternative to Goodreads 📚
•84•

7yr ago

View allStart new thread
Links
bookclub.cool
Social
X.com
Makers
Ben Lang
Alex Banaga
Henry Kaufman
Jordan Gonen
Jacob Schein
All Makers

What do you think about bookclub?

Leave a review for the community

What do people think of bookclub?

The community submitted 16 reviews to tell us what they like about bookclub, what bookclub can do better, and more.

4/5All time (16 reviews)
1/5
Recently (0 reviews)
Best
Any Rating
Stewart Henderson
Stewart Henderson
•8 reviews

It would be nice to partition books into read, want to read, etc. Also sharing functionality would be great.

Share
Report
7yr ago
Thierry Maout
Thierry Maout
•10 reviews

I'm a big fan of Goodreads as a concept but the product itself is often confusing and frustrating. bookclub has a great potential to offer an alternative. I hope to see the product grow in features while keeping that simple aesthetic and UX, which is what frustrates me most about goodreads. Lots of good suggestions already in the reviews, I'm looking forward to seeing more form you guys!

Share
Report
7yr ago
ahounou khaled
ahounou khaled
•5 reviews

Hi @jrdngonen !

Some suggestions :

1- Give directly focus on the input zone when adding new books. It's tiring to drag the mouse in again and again

2- Find some inventive way to add new books. Here are some suggestions :

*add books from previous platforms: Amazon reading list, Goodreads...

*make possible to choose tag about authors and categories and books should appear and you have just to check them with check button to add them all at once (add single book each time is tiring)

3-make possible to organize books by collections and each collection can be assigned to a knowledge tree. So people who have read a lot of books can easily guide newcomers to where to start and the path to go to become master in a domain.

4-add notes or badge to users whose collections or knowledge tree are shared the most and who respond to newcomers in the domains their knowledge trees are about. A system like Wikipedia or StackOverflow

*help the collection and knowledge trees owners demonstrate their expertise by making periodic quiz and challenges about their domains (you can guess by the kind of book they read)

5- Find a way to bring already successful authors (for eg: by creating a profile for them they can claim later) and make possible to people to interact with them by asking questions about their books

6- Business model suggestion: Use data about collections and knowledge trees accessed by users to advertise newly released books to a specific target.

7- Use renowned expert in some domain (eg: Bill Gates, Marc Zuck, Steve Blank, Sean Ellis...) create a profile for them and import their read books to apply when possible the above suggestions

8- a last but not urging thing to add: make possible to add a comment about a book and half-start for more specific notes about books

That's all for now. If I find something new, will edit and update this post

Share
Report
7yr ago
Sharif Shameem
Sharif Shameem
•1 review

What better way to step up my book game than to publish my bookshelf on the internet for the world to see!

Share
Report
7yr ago
Pierre-Marie Galite
Pierre-Marie Galite
Meddler

Meddler

•6 reviews
Share
Report
7yr ago
Niesha Kennedy-Robinson
Niesha Kennedy-Robinson
•4 reviews

Seems like a big ad for the Amazon Affiliate Program. or an undercover sales website. Forced social media login, no email address only login. No way to interact with friends to see what they are reading, yet it says it's an alternative to Goodreads. No way to add books you've already read from Amazon since they are a part of the affiliate program, this would be a great addition.

Oh yeah, no app!

Share
Report
7yr ago
Shahbaz Syed
Shahbaz Syed
•1 review

Citing GDPR to deny service to a product is not an excuse for a digital product.

Share
Report
7yr ago
Hao Jiang
Hao Jiang
•5 reviews
Share
Report
7yr ago
Brian Rose
Brian Rose
Google

Google

•7 reviews
Share
Report
7yr ago
Lauren Weiniger
Lauren Weiniger
Safely

Safely

•3 reviews
Share
Report
5yr ago

You might also like

Read This Twice
Read This Twice
Books worth reading twice.
Bookself
Bookself
The social reading app 📚💬
Self-Quarantine Book Club
Self-Quarantine Book Club
Stuck inside? Join a book club on our Slack community.
Juno
Juno
The social reading app for desktop and mobile
Lybrum
Lybrum
The new way to experience books, together.
Is this book good?
Is this book good?
Avoid making bad book purchases
View more