PooPail receives mixed reviews, with users appreciating its large capacity and effective scooping mechanism. However, many criticize its build quality, citing issues with bag attachment, stability, and durability. Some users report that the pail is prone to tipping over and that the handle feels fragile. There are also complaints about the lid not fitting tightly, allowing flies to breed. While some users are satisfied with its design and ease of use, others feel it is overpriced and poorly constructed. Overall, the product's execution seems to fall short of its promising concept.