I love connecting with smart folks I've met through the internet IRL which is why I'm always interested to learn about new online-to-offline businesses. Amusemi is very similar to Grubwithus, a service I used early on a few times but eventually shut down/pivoted ~year ago (http://allthingsd.com/20131127/g...).
Amusemi is only available in NYC at this time.
Product Hunt