Women and diversity in communities
Rosie Sherry
3 replies
I stumbled upon an article on what women want in communities (https://coralproject.net/blog/what-women-want-in-community/). It stuck out to me because I’m not sure I’ve come across resources specifically on women and diversity before and that kind of feels so wrong.
I’d love to explore it more in the future.
The post covers community behaviours women and men tend to have:
Many women
- Post shorter messages.
- Tend to drop out when they get no response.
- Express support of others.
- Look for common ground with questioners.
- Speak less in mixed groups.
- Are more aggressive in majority male groups.
- Become more upset with violations of civility.
- Value social harmony.
- Feel better when they know someone is enforcing rules.
- Say the loss of privacy is the biggest problem of the internet.
Many men
- Write longer messages.
- Tend to begin and end discussions in mixed groups.
- Take adversarial approach to questioners.
- More commonly use crude or abusive language, tolerate adversity.
- Less aggressive in majority female groups.
- Less likely to value social harmony.
- Are more upset about threats to free expression.
- Say censorship is one of the biggest problems of the internet.
Building community for diversity is something I’m hyper sensitive to. -The first thing I look for when I join communities or follow people online is whether they appear to support diversity.
It’s pretty amazing how many men are oblivious to what ‘women’ think of them.
I just dropped into a business podcast to listen to the hosts laugh and not understand why they don’t have women showing up at their events and as followers. I could give a million reasons why. That experience was just one of them.
What I also get a lot is lack of credit. I feel women often share things, ideas, and experiences. And then men often build upon them without giving due credit. The challenging thing is that often they don’t realise they are doing it.
It’s lots of little things like this that can often be dismissed as not important, but for women it’s like death by a thousand cuts.
Why should we share stuff, if often we feel taken advantage of, instead of supported and uplifted? (It doesn't stop me now, but it definitely has in the past).
It feels like it doesn’t do us favours and we often end up spending our energy on pointing out the injustices, like I’m doing right now.
Just some quick thoughts on the challenges of building community with women in mind. 😇
Replies
Shi Ling@taishiling
UI-licious
Thank you for writing and sharing your observations and thoughts publicly! Well put, I share the same sentiments but often find it hard to put to words when people ask me how can we invite more women working in tech to join online and offline communities. Men have ask me me why we even need to have women-only groups like Women Who Code, and collectively my female friends and I simply answer that we just feel more welcomed and supported by these communities (and we want to have learning spaces, without judgement, competition, and flexing).
Share
Research Buddy
Thanks Rosie for this thoughtful post.
I found it useful that you listed out some differences there can be in approach between men and women. It provides a framework for thinking about what may be helpful in groups that involve both.
Very interesting post and conversation, thank you for sharing 🙏