How do you determine if a product is good or bad?

Question

Accepted Answer

The revenue of the product, I think :)

Gurkaran Singh · Answer

Determining if a product is good or bad is like finding bugs in code – you gotta test it thoroughly to unveil its true potential!

Hossein Yazdi · Answer

I consider it's UI, UX, idea, and features. These are the most important metrics for me!

Ven Fauzia · Answer

@vertikanigam Thank you for your detailed perspective! It's true that judging a product solely by its MVP can be misleading, as it might not reflect the full potential. Understanding personal needs and seeing how a product meets and exceeds them is crucial. Regular improvements and a clear roadmap are indeed strong indicators of a reliable product and team. How do you typically track a product's development history and future plans?

Ven Fauzia · Answer

@solyou Absolutely, addressing the specific needs of the target audience is crucial for any product’s success. Contentify AI seems promising for automating social media content creation. It’s great to see a solution that aims to save time and enhance online presence effectively. I'll definitely check out the free trial of Contentify AI to see how it can help with creating engaging social media content. Thanks for sharing!

Vertika Nigam · Answer

Sometimes people judge by looking at the MVP. That decision could go wrong.

However, if the product is fully functional, you need to first know what your own needs are.

If the product is fulfilling those needs, maybe solving a few more things that you never thought were problematic, also there's a good history showing how regularly the product is improved and they have a proper roadmap of how things would be better in the coming months/years with at least ONE innovative addition -

It's a great product and a great team you can trust.

Chris · Answer

I believe the quality of a product is ultimately determined by how well it solves a real problem for its target audience. User feedback, engagement metrics, and retention rates can all provide valuable insights into the effectiveness of a product. Additionally, conducting thorough market research and staying abreast of industry trends can help ensure that the product remains competitive and relevant in the ever-evolving tech landscape.

Arthur Leclercq · Answer

I take a look to what the product is promising, if their promise fits with what happens, it is a good one

Fabian Maume · Answer

Is your question about selecting a product to buy or deciding if you should keep on developing your own product?

Ricardo · Answer

@arthur_leclercq Hi Arthur! would you like to check out my ideas? would that be good? https://www.producthunt.com/disc...

Sol Yousefi ☀️ · Answer

@ven_fauzia I would appreciate your feedback

Vertika Nigam · Answer

@ven_fauzia There’s no single way to do that.

If a product has been in existence for decades, then these kind of information is often documented by multiple magazines and blogs.

If it’s a recent tech product, most companies show their product’s roadmap briefly.

Ven Fauzia · Answer

@arthur_leclercq Thank you for your insight! Evaluating whether a product lives up to its promises is definitely a key factor. Consistency between marketing claims and actual performance is crucial. Do you also consider other factors, such as customer reviews or expert opinions, in your assessment?

Ven Fauzia · Answer

@hosseinyazdi Thanks for sharing your criteria! Evaluating a product based on its UI, UX, idea, and features is indeed important. A good interface and user experience can significantly enhance the overall value of a product. How do you prioritize these metrics when one might excel in one area but fall short in another?

How do you determine if a product is good or bad?

Replies